
With Halloween just around the corner, I thought it might be wise to address a topic that I am very, very passionate about. Candy. As a father of four living in a standard California cookie cutter neighborhood (granted, a very nice and tidy cookie cutter neighborhood, I don’t want to be accused of driving my home value down any more than it already is!) I stand to bring in quite a haul on Halloween night. And much like a Mafia Don, Big Tony is going to be sure to get a piece of the pie.
Thankfully this year, Halloween falls on a Saturday. To be honest, it doesn’t matter to me if it falls on a school night, I’m going to wet my beak, or get a taste of the action (pun intended) before the kids go to bed regardless so having them not have to pull out of a candy hangover at 7 AM is a bonus. As a veteran now of over a decade sending out my candy minions to do my dirty work, I have developed a sorting system that I’m happy to share with you.
First, all candy undergoes a standard safety inspection. I’m sure we’ve all heard horror stories of razor blades and the like being inserted into Nestle Crunch bars as well as Kit Kat’s and Snickers. And if you haven’t, well, now you have and you can thank me from your chocolate-induced coma later. I remove these “A-list” candies immediately from the kid’s bags and put them into a large Ziploc labeled “Dad” which I tell them is a trash bag. Trust me; these will definitely be disposed of.
Next we run a series of tests on the remaining candies. Tootsie Rolls are bent and squeezed to check for freshness and a Butterfinger or two is sacrificed right on the spot to check consistency, or more specifically, if these were left over from last year. If the kids get home early enough these go into the bowl to hand out to the neighborhood kids along with the black and orange colored taffy. I have a theory that those were made once back in the 50’s and we’re still working off of that initial batch. If we’re too late to hand them back out, they get put into the “eat only when desperate” bag.
You then take your Hershey’s Chocolate, M&M’s, Skittles, Nerds, Runts and Laffy Taffy and put those into an “B-list” pile. These will be in the immediate rotation, meaning they’ll be snacked upon throughout the day in small enough doses that the calories will never really “stick.” Yes, this is another one of my theories. M&M’s used to be put in the “Dad” bag but I took exception with them, or more specifically the packaging. I, for one, don’t find much “Fun” in a “Fun Size” bag that contains 7 peanut M&M’s. It takes me about 5 or 6 “Fun Size” bags to even start remotely having fun and by that time I have a pretty “Pathetic Size” pile of wrappers sitting in front of me.
Finally we divide up the “C-listers” such as the Bottle Caps, Milk Duds, Dots and Smarties amongst the kids. I’ll let them keep the Milky Way’s and Three Musketeers’ as well as the Hershey’s Kisses just so they look like they made out alright. Let me be perfectly clear, the contents of your piles may vary. I once met a girl who loved the Root Beer Bottle Caps and would have clearly put them on the “A-list.” She was wrong, but entitled to her opinion nonetheless.
When the kids were little they tired easily and often didn’t earn their keep. To compensate I learned the fine art of turning off the porch light to preserve what was left in our own candy bowl. But with age and a slowing metabolism my wife no longer wants any part of the Halloween haul so she started buying the yucky candy to hand out so that she wouldn’t be tempted. If you’re looking for quantity over quality, hit my house up right before bed time and I’ll empty the remainder of the bowl in your pillow case for an even half-hearted “Trick or Treat!”
Inevitably, though, too much of a good thing can indeed get old. We’ll hit the candy buffet hard for the first few days and eventually the thrill of the haul is gone. The Kit Kat’s lose a bit of their bite, the Snickers don’t quite satisfy and the Crunch bars aren’t so crunchy. Not to worry, though, the kid’s candy bags quickly disappear only to find their contents magically lining the bottom of their Christmas stockings, my minions, I mean my kids, none the wiser.

